I’ve always wondered about banoffee pie. The only time I had ever really heard about it is in that scene in Love Actually where Keira Knightley’s character shows up at her husband’s friends house looking for a wedding tape and offers him a slice of banoffee pie or ‘munchies.’ Many people probably don’t remember the scene in this much detail but as it’s my favourite movie I could probably recite the whole thing backwards.
Anyways, I always wondered what banoffee pie is, I also wondered exactly what ‘munchies’ are but in America they cover a pretty broad range so I didn’t spend as much time contemplating that. I finally had the chance to try banoffee pie earlier this year when my roommate made it for a going away party. And it was show stopping amazing. This recipe is a little untraditional since there are pretzels in the crust but they provide a great salty balance to the sweet caramel. There is also crème fraîche in the topping which offsets the sweetness of the pouring cream as well.
Albeit an amazing dish, it’s not the easiest. It’s mostly straight-forward but this recipe doesn’t spend a lot of time explaining just how to caramelise the sugar. And it turns out caramelised sugar is a bitch.
Maybe it’s just my ineptitude in the kitchen but it took me three times to get it right. On my first attempt it burnt- filling up my kitchen with the smell of gross black caramel. The next time the sugar seemed to dissolve and then somehow magically turned back into sugar from liquid. To be honest, I almost scrapped the whole thing after that. But I was not about to let caramel best me. It seemed to be finding all sorts of different ways to laugh at me. I think the problem was that I had the heat too high so the sugar didn’t have time to fully dissolve before the mixture started bubbling.
I used this tutorial after the first two attempts and the photos are really helpful.
No matter how tricksy caramel may be, this recipe is perfect for any special occasion.
- 3 ripe bananas, thinly sliced
- 300 ml pouring cream
- 400 gm crème fraîche
- Scraped seeds of 1 vanilla bean
- To serve: shaved dark chocolate
- Pretzel crumb base
- 240 gm digestive biscuits, coarsely broken
- 90 gm salted pretzels
- 75 gm caster sugar
- 200 gm butter, melted
- Salted toffee
- 200 gm caster sugar
- 80 gm butter, coarsely chopped
- 125 ml pouring cream
- For pretzel crumb base, process biscuits, pretzels and sugar in a food processor until fine crumbs form, add butter, pulse to just combine, press into base and up sides of a 5cm-deep, 24cm-diameter pie dish and refrigerate until set.
- Meanwhile, for salted toffee, stir sugar and 50ml water in a saucepan over medium heat until sugar dissolves, bring to the boil and cook until caramel (6-8 minutes). Add butter, cream and ½ tsp sea salt flakes (be careful as hot caramel will spit), stir until combined, then pour over crumb base and refrigerate until chilled.
- Arrange banana on top of caramel and set aside. Whisk cream, crème fraîche and vanilla seeds in an electric mixer until firm peaks form. Spoon on top of banana, scatter with chocolate shavings and serve.